aging rock music

Today is my 49th birthday… typically this would be considered “old”, especially for a rock musician. Strangely we don’t consider 49 old for blues or jazz musicians nor classical musicians or composers. But rock music came into being as a young person’s game, a rebellion against the old people’s ideas, and as such became sold to the public as “only for the young”. One result of that is of course the sad Hollywood adulation of youth idea, and that permeates the marketing of music still. Young is better. Even if the young have nothing of substance to say.

When rock started in the 50s, there wasn’t much to say but “fuck off, daddio” and “let’s have sex, baby”, which weren’t things very commonly said publicly. And indeed, much of rock music subsequently has said the same things. What’s weird is that as people grew up with these things, some people still were offended by sex and “newness” and hence, even as the rock musicians grew old, some people of all ages still had to say “fuck off, the man!” and “let’s have sex.” Personally I’m all for these sentiments, always have been. And I’ll probably be telling the man to fuck off and saying to my wife some form of “let’s do it” for the rest of my life. And offending some people, hopefully.

One thing that amazes me, though, is that the rock musicians that are even now still the icons were good when they were young. Eric Clapton, Jimi Hendrix, Jimmy Page, Carlos Santana, Peter Green, Jerry Garcia, Frank Zappa, Sid Barrett: these guys were all in their 20s in the 1960s, when they made significant statements and changed the vocabulary and sonic palette of the guitar. I’m as old as I am and I feel like I’m just starting to get good. (please allow me another decade at least before I can say I’m a violinist instead of a guitar player who plays violin.)

So how’d these guys get so good so young? Was it practicing? Better music education in school? Cheaper to live so more time to dedicate to playing? It’s hard to know. But there has rarely been a time subsequently when such a burst of change came to guitar playing. I know that the 80s we had the Van Halen into shredder action revolution, but besides the guys who were actually laden with ideas (perhaps Steve Vai and Joe Satriani?) not much of that survived as part of the current language of rock guitar playing. And after that, well, I wouldn’t say Sonic Youth are awesome guitar players so much as awesome composers who expanded the palette and vocabulary further.

When the good musicians expanded the genre, the genre expanded what it could say. It had more color and musical language, more types of poetic language to match. Rock grew a lot in the late 60s and 70s. And then overgrew, collapsed, was reborn into new ways of saying the old basic truths, but… then then the 80s didn’t say any more than that, most of the time. Nobody developed a poetic language that could match the shred, and punk pretty much stuck with “fuck off, daddio”. By the 90s the whole underground music that wasn’t punk or metal had become co-opted by the music business machine, and the lyrical language was growing, but for some reason there was still a stigma left over from punk and metal: no guitar solos if you’re punk, ‘cuz that’s what metal dudes do. What was underground in the world of “Alternative” rock was progressive rock!

We still value youth in rock music. Every year it’s about the new bands, and every year I’m disappointed in the new bands’ musical abilities. Occasionally something will jump out and work for a while, but a lot of these are looks backwards at the 60s or 70s music (which I like, and I admit I go retro quite a lot) so they don’t seem to last long enough to actually develop into a new thing.

Meanwhile, like me, the old rockers are getting better at playing. Culture as a whole isn’t interested much, but luckily for some of us, there are still fans, and now these fans are bringing their kids. I personally know quite a few amazing musicians who are around my age or (gasp!) older. And I don’t mean the aging rock stars, I mean the aging rock musicians.

Let’s hope we can keep going.

musician. real person. that's my real name, go ahead, look me up.

Tagged with: ,
Posted in etc., Music
4 comments on “aging rock music
  1. Happy Birthday Jonathan. Keep on Rockin’.

  2. Jim Omalley says:

    i am 48 and have been experiencing the same feeling about new music and where its headed. i am a big fan of particular eras and genres that made an impact in the past. i no longer see any kind of cultural change, i believe nirvana was the last one and i am not sure if that was a good thing or a bad thing…instead of expanding i believe it shut down what everyone was working for in the 80’s especially in the indie scene…i do as well tend to listen to a lot of new music, however i always tend to find joy in artists rooted in the 60’s or 70’s..
    jim omalley

  3. I think there is some good new music. I really like St. Vincent, Jesca Hoop, The Low Anthem, Beirut, Joanna Newsom, and Jonathan Coulton, among others. Of course, I still go back and listen to the stuff I’ve loved for decades (including CvB of course). I saw CvB live at least once at the I-Beam when I was a DJ at KUSF in 1988/89.

    Hey, I am exactly two weeks older than you.

  4. […] year I wrote a blog about aging rock musicians. I was turning 49. Today I turn 50! Like good wine, they say, you know… it turns to vinegar if […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

photo by Ian Weintraub

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

%d bloggers like this: